The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives cast’s net worths: Taylor Frankie Paul, Whitney Leavitt, Jen Affleck, and more

NorahC

0 3 minutes read

Hulu’s hit show, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, has made stars across a variety of programs of its leads, although it has also been mired in controversy

he Secret Lives of Mormon Wives remains a show that’s as popular as it is divisive, earning scores of fans transferring over from the #MomTok sphere, while also stirring up drama over the personal lives of its cast.

While four seasons of the show have already been released, the last arriving on March 12, 2026, production on the fifth was paused after more domestic violence allegations were made public against cast member Taylor Frankie Paul by her ex Dakota Mortensen, throwing the show’s future for a loop.

Over the years, though, the show’s cast members have been able to make quite a pretty penny, not only through TV appearance fees, but sponsorships, endorsements, and work in other spheres. Find out more on their eye-watering net worths below (spoiler alert: while none of these figures are confirmed, these are collated from multiple reports)…

Taylor Frankie Paul

Taylor is a TikTok star who gained traction online for being open about her Mormon lifestyle, motherhood and relationship. Due to her candid nature, she became known prominently the MomTok community.

However, her contentious and very public disputes with ex Dakota have impacted her recent opportunities, including being abruptly removed as the lead for the currently-canceled season of The Bachelorette. Some reports say her net worth fluctuates between $400,000 and $3 million, though no confirmed figures exist.

Demi Engemann

Demi is also a member of the MomTok community and she shares her lifestyle and family life online as a content creator. Her net worth is between $1 million and $5 million, per multiple reports, mostly through her work as an influencer.

Jen Affleck

Jen is also an influencer who openly discusses motherhood, faith and postpartum hardships on her social media.

Only a few months after giving birth to her third child, she participated in season 34 of Dancing With the Stars, controversially being eliminated in ninth place. Her net worth is $1 million to $5 million, per multiple reports.

Jessi Ngatikaura

Jessi is a content creator who shared her parenting tips and hair how-tos, as well as personal anecdotes on social media. Aside from the online world, she is also the owner of her own hair salon called JZ Styles.

On top of that, she has launched her own hair products. Her net worth is $1.65 million, per Cinematic Central, although that is currently also being impacted by her divorce from Jordan Ngatikaura.

Layla Taylor

Layla is originally from Arizona, however, she moved to Utah once she graduated high school and then converted to Mormonism. She made her debut as the cast member on the show during the first season, and then became a principal cast member in 2025 for the second season. Her net worth is between $1 and $5 million per Distractify.

Mayci Neeley

Mayci was a former Division 1 tennis player at Brigham Young University. She went on to become the founder of her natal nutrition brand called Baby Mama and has gotten a big fan base for her helpful products.

She also released her memoir Told You So in October 2025. Her net worth is between $500,000 and $750,000 per House and Whips.

Mikayla Matthews

Mikayla is also an influencer and her content focuses on motherhood, as well as her personal struggles with chronic illness, eczema, and small intestinal bacterial overgrowth. Her net worth is $5 million, per Net Worth Spot, boosted especially by her social media partnerships.

Whitney Leavitt

Whitney was previously a professional dancer and attended Brigham Young University for dance, where she earned a bachelor’s degree in dance in 2018. She competed on Dancing with the Stars alongside Jen, and despite being a strong favorite in the ballroom, negative audience reception meant her journey ended at the semifinals in sixth place.

Her stint on the show led her to make her Broadway debut playing Roxie Hart in Chicago, with her six-week stint being extended for two more weeks and breaking the show’s box office records. She will next star in and executive produce the film All for Love. Her net worth is $1 million, per multiple reports, although has also been quoted as high as $2.5 million.